The 2K Showcase mode features historical matches with specific objectives to recreate iconic moments. Completing these objectives unlocks new Superstars, arenas, and attires. Each match has a list of required actions, so pay close attention to the on-screen prompts.

- Historical Recreations: Follow the on-screen prompts to perform specific moves, reversals, and sequences from the actual match.
- Hidden Objectives: Some matches may have secret objectives that unlock bonus content. Experiment with different actions.
- Difficulty Tiers: Completing objectives on higher difficulties can yield greater rewards.
- Unlockable Content: Successfully completing matches and objectives unlocks Superstars, arenas, and gear for use in other modes.