Follow the Return 2: The Heart walkthrough for Alan Wake 2: The Lake House to track Nightingale, find the Heart at the General Store, and get the Sawed-off Shotgun.
Walkthrough:
- Follow Alex down the shortcut towards the crime scene.
- Pass the FBC station and observe the people outside, including Ilmo Koskela. You can enter the station to read a Maintenance Note.
- Continue following Alex to the crime scene, which is flooded.
- Examine the makeshift sacrificial altar for the double triangle sign.
- Examine the table for a clue and speak to Alex.
- Head in the direction indicated by the triangles to find bare footprints, presumably Nightingale's.
- Follow the path to the water's edge, wade in, and collect supplies from an emergency cabinet.
- Follow the flooded path south past the Witch's Ladle sign until you reach the tree where the trail previously ended.
- Examine the tracks on the tree and approach the shimmering area.
- Boost your torch (R1) to burn away the darkness and reveal the Manuscript Page (4/56) titled "Saga Finds a Safe Haven".
- Backtrack and locate the ledge leading to the Witch's Hut.
- As you approach, Alex will radio to say he is checking something in the woods.
- Examine the fuse box on the side of the hut; a fuse is missing.
- Cross the bridge to the west and search the blue boxes to find a working fuse.
- Return to the hut and use the fuse on the fuse box to restore power.
- Enter the hut to unlock the Coffee Thermos trophy and access the Break Room.
- Examine the Shoebox to find unlocked weapons and charms from previous playthroughs.
- On the table with the coffee thermos, find the Manuscript Page (52/56) titled "Dark Poem 1".
- Grab supplies from a cabinet and search the shelves in the corner for the Manuscript Page (5/56) titled "Saga Opens the Cauldron Lake Overlap".
- Return to the Mind Place, open Robert Nightingale's profile, and select the Overlap topic.
- Go to the Case Board, open the Murder at Cauldron Lake case, and place the collected clues against the Where Did Nightingale Go? question.
- Place the Cauldron Lake Witch's Hut key image on the board to unlock the What Is the Ritual? question.
- Place the manuscript clues against the new question to add Where is the Heart? and Words on the Heart?.
- Saga will deduce that the ritual requires finding Nightingale's heart and placing it through the hole in the Witch's Ladle sign to open the Overlap.
- Return to Nightingale's profile, select The Heart topic, then The Heart! Where Is It?.
- Saga will determine that Nightingale's heart is in the General Store.
- Return to the Case Board, place the new clue against Where is the Heart?.
- Open the Cult of the Tree case, place the "Triangle carving" clue against Cult Symbols...? to unlock another clue for Cult Psychology...?.
- Leave the Witch's Hut and take the path southeast and south to the General Store.
- Proceed towards the back of the store, where a cultist will break through the wall.
- Darkness Coiled / Chasing the Source / Aimed Ahead: Press R1 to burn away the enemy's Darkness Shield, unlocking a trophy. A red area called a Source Point will appear on the enemy's torso. Shoot the Source Point for significant damage and unlock a second trophy. Finish the enemy with a couple of rounds to the skull; a third trophy is for killing five enemies with headshots.
- If you took damage, exit the store and stand under the light to recover health.
- Enter the room the enemy emerged from and find a hip pouch on a filing cabinet.
- Picking up the pouch adds four inventory spaces, unlocking the Grew Bigger trophy.
- Examine the locked gun cabinet on the wall; the clue for the combination is
100% Human-Written. AI Fact-Checked. Community Verified. Learn how AntMag verifies content