Guide to finding all 8 'Mystery Man' collectibles in Until Dawn, including Wanted Posters, Newspaper Fragments, and more. Learn their locations and significance.
This guide covers the 8 'Mystery Man' clues found throughout Until Dawn. These clues are primarily related to the fabricated 'Psycho Killer' story created by Josh. While they don't directly impact gameplay choices, they provide backstory and context to the unfolding events.
- Clue 1 - Wanted Poster
Chapter: 1 - Memento Mori/Friendship
Location: Lower Cable Car Station, on the outside wall. The game prompts you to examine this.
Description: A torn wanted poster for Victor Milgram, dated 1998, wanted for arson and death threats. This was created by Josh. - Clue 2 - Newspaper Fragment
Chapter: 2 - Jealousy/Darkness
Location: Lodge Storage Room, in a utility closet near the window Chris breaks into.
Description: A fake newspaper clipping from June 5, 1997, detailing the conviction of ex-janitor Victor Milgram for arson at Blackwood Pines and his vow of revenge on the Washington family. This was also created by Josh. - Clue 3 - Answerphone Message
Chapter: 2 - Jealousy/Darkness
Location: Lodge Dining Room, on the sideboard at the back.
Description: A recorded message from a police officer about a convict's release, intended as a warning. This is revealed to be Josh's voice. - Clue 4 - Axe Holder
Chapter: 2 - Jealousy/Darkness
Location: Washington Lodge Exterior, on the wall near the window Chris breaks into.
Description: A wall-mounted axe holder, notably missing its axe. The axe is later found at the Cable Car Station. - Clue 5 - Cigar Stub
Chapter: 2 - Jealousy/Darkness
Location: Mines, on a red barrel to the right after ascending the stairs.
Description: A recently stubbed-out cigar, suggesting someone else is present on the mountain. The label matches a cigar box from the Sanatorium. - Clue 6 - Mystical Symbol
Chapter: 2 - Jealousy/Darkness
Location: Mines, on the wall to the right after ascending the stairs, behind the red barrel.
Description: Strange symbols painted on the mine wall, intended to ward off evil spirits according to the Native American book. - Clue 7 - Native American Book
Chapter: 3 - Haunted/Isolation
Location: Washington Cabin, on a table next to the fireplace.
Description: A book detailing Native American symbols used for communication, warnings, and protection against evil spirits. - Clue 8 - Postcard
Chapter: 2 - Jealousy/Darkness
Location: Washington Lodge, in Hannah's bedroom, to the right of the bathroom.
100% Human-Written. AI Fact-Checked. Community Verified. Learn how AntMag verifies content