Follow Matt and Emily down the mountain path in Until Dawn, discover a gruesome clue, and then switch to Mike for a spooky tractor encounter and a vital totem.
Alright, so after that last bit, you'll actually hear a noise off in the distance. Time to go check it out! Head back down the steps and take the path to your left. You'll need to drop down at the end of it. Keep following the path – Emily's going straight, but if you want a little detour, you can go up the stairs on the right. It'll put you on the other side of that gate you saw earlier, though it's still locked, so no biggie. Stick with Emily, and you'll eventually stumble upon something pretty grim: a pig's head on a stake with a note. Grab that note, it's a CLUE!
Collectible Found: MYSTERY MAN #31 (PIG HEAD NOTE) - This is found in Chapter 2: Jealousy/Darkness, out on the mountain with Matt and Emily.
After that, we've got a cutscene, and then we're jumping over to the Analyst. He's trying to gauge how honest you've been with your in-game choices. The key here is to be honest about how you've *played* the game, not necessarily how you'd act in real life. If you contradict your character's actions, the Analyst will notice and cut the session short, which makes it less interesting. To get the most out of it, just be truthful about your gameplay. He'll then ask you about loyalty, honesty, and charity – pick whatever you like, as it doesn't actually change anything gameplay-wise, just Dr. Hill's dialogue.
Now, we're heading into Chapter Three: Haunted/Isolation. You'll start as Ashley in the Washington Lodge Library at 23:00. Josh, Chris, and Ashley are going to try and conduct a séance, and Chris suggests Ashley should ask the spirits the questions. You'll get to pick a few questions, but honestly, none of your choices here will change the game's outcome, stats, or relationships. So, pick whatever feels right. Basically, one of the sisters will reveal they were murdered and that there's proof in the library. Josh will get upset and storm off, even though it was his idea. Just so you know, everyone's relationship with JOSH goes down a bit after this.
Next up, we switch to Mike on the Path to the Cabin at 23:22. After Mike hops the fence, head over to the old tractor and check it out – opening the door will give you a jump scare. If you're looking for an easily missed TOTEM, go left from the tractor and follow the path to the very end.
Collectible Found: DANGER TOTEM #2 - Found in Chapter 3: Haunted/Isolation, while searching for Jessica. After Mike examines the tractor for a jumpscare, go left to find this Totem. The vision shows a stag getting enraged.
Head back to the tractor now and follow the path all the way to the right. Yep, it's predictable – Jessica teases Mike, and you get a dialogue choice. You can be GRUMPY ('Fine, you win.') which makes Mike's ROMANTIC and FUNNY meters go down, and his relationship with Jess also goes down. Or you can be WITTY ('Gotta try harder, Jess.') which makes Mike's FUNNY meter go UP, his ROMANTIC meter go DOWN, and improves his relationship with Jess. After a quick cutscene, you'll regain control. Grab the TOTEM on the floor right in front of you.
Collectible Found: GUIDANCE TOTEM #3 - Found in Chapter 3: Haunted/Isolation. After Jessica scares Mike, this Totem is on the floor to the left of the bridge. The vision shows Sam climbing a ledge opposite a waterwheel.
If you're up for finding something else interesting, you can head towards the...
100% Human-Written. AI Fact-Checked. Community Verified. Learn how AntMag verifies content