Navigate Chapter 4 of Until Dawn, 'Malevolence/Loyalty.' Guide Chris through the Sanatorium, find clues, totems, and make a critical choice between saving Ashley or Josh.
Mike luckily finds another lamp now. Set it alight so you can see.
Mike follows the guy out into the wilderness, and sees him heading towards the old Sanatorium. Guess where Mike's going next?
CHRIS - WASHINGTON LODGE (00:41)
Now conscious, but very much alone, make Chris head forward. On the left corner before you turn, pick up Ashley's purse from the ground. Now go through the double doors and examine the blood on the wall. Follow the corridor and exit the lodge.
Go down the stairs and follow the blood trail down the path. When presented with a fork in the road, go left. Keep going until... BAM! By the way, this mannequin looks different depending on your choices with the analyst earlier.
Go behind the mannequin and examine the pig's head on the floor for another CLUE.
COLLECTIBLE - MYSTERY MAN CLUE #15: PIG'S HEAD
Chapter: 4 - Malevolence/Loyalty
Found By: Chris
Location: While you are searching for Ashley, you'll come across a fork in the path. Go left, and this will be behind the scary mannequin.
On the floor to the left of this pig's head is a TOTEM.
COLLECTIBLE - DEATH TOTEM #4
Chapter: 4 - Malevolence/Loyalty
Found By: Chris
Location: While you are searching for Ashley, you'll come across a fork in the path. Go left, and this will be behind the scary mannequin.
Vision: Chris is lifted off his feet and into the air by an unknown source.
Go back down the path and take the right turn now. Follow the path all the way to a huge shed. DO NOT ENTER THE SHED YET. Go around the back, where you will eventually find another TOTEM on the ground.
COLLECTIBLE - LOSS TOTEM #3
Chapter: 4 - Malevolence/Loyalty
Found By: Chris
Location: While searching for Ashley, you come across a large shed. Before you enter, go around the back of the shed to find this on the ground in a clearing.
Vision: Ashley's decapitated head rolls on the ground.
Now you can enter the shed.
Make your way through the darkness, listening to Ashley's voice, and walk towards the window.
CUTSCENE
You now have to make a nasty decision. Do you make Chris save his best friend, Josh? Or should he save his crush, Ashley? You decide.
Buuuut, if you like things spoiled for you, or you already know what happens, you are more than welcome to read what will happen below!
Butterfly Effect: ...AND WHICH ONE WILL DIE
IF YOU CHOOSE TO SAVE ASHLEY:
Pull the lever towards Josh. The saw slowly moves forward...and Josh sliced clean in two! His guts spill out onto the floor as Chris watches in horror.
- CHRIS SAID THAT HE WOULD SAVE ASHLEY.
IF YOU CHOOSE TO SAVE JOSH:
Pull the lever towards Ashley. However, the voice announces that you have chosen to kill Josh and save Ashley! Chris panics, as this is not what he wanted. The saw moves slowly forward...before slicing Josh in half! His guts spill out onto the floor as Chris watches in horror.
- CHRIS SAID THAT HE WOULD SAVE JOSH, BUT THEN DIDN'T
IF YOU LET THE TIME RUN OUT WITHOUT MOVING THE LEVER:
The saw will head towards Josh, before slicing him in half. Your Butterfly Effect will depend on who you SAID you would save.
100% Human-Written. AI Fact-Checked. Community Verified. Learn how AntMag verifies content