Oh, Brother

Follow our Red Dead Redemption 2 'Oh, Brother' walkthrough to help settle the feud between the brothers, including the Valentine brawl and the Cumberland Falls stunt.

Alright, so you've probably rested up a bit since the last time you dealt with these two jokers. Good news: they're back at it! This time, you'll find them bickering behind the saloon in Valentine. Their big idea to settle things? Apparently, it involves you punching them. Yeah, you heard that right. Just walk up to each brother and mash that button to give 'em a good jaw-rattler. Then, you'll need to land a gut punch, followed by a swift kick to the… well, you know. Get all three hits in on both of them, and this part of the mission will wrap up.

Now, you'll need to give it another couple of days of in-game time before the final act kicks off. This time, the destination is Cumberland Falls, which is located west and a little south of Valentine. Keep an eye on your map; you're looking for the top of the falls, just under the location's name. You'll know you're close when that familiar “?” marker pops up. Helen will be down by the shore, while the brothers will be up at the top of the falls. Head over to them to start the finale.

Their grand plan to impress Helen? They're going to ride over the falls in a barrel. Seriously. After they've crammed themselves in, you'll see a prompt on your screen – usually in the lower right corner. Go ahead and hit that button to give the barrel a good shove. Watch them go! After that dramatic exit, you and Helen will naturally go check on them. Follow the trail heading west and south until you reach the new marked spot on your map. You'll find the brothers washed up on the shore, looking a bit dazed. They'll start questioning their life choices and what they've been doing, eventually wandering off and leaving Helen behind. And that, my friend, is the end of the 'Oh, Brother' mission chain.