Follow our detailed walkthrough for Red Dead Redemption 2's 'Who is Not Without Sin' mission. Learn how to complete Poker, handle a creditor, and get Reverend Swanson home.
Alright, let's tackle the 'Who is Not Without Sin' mission in Chapter 2. You'll start by heading to Flatneck Station, which is southwest of Horseshoe Overlook. Look for Reverend Swanson inside the building; he'll be pretty deep into a game of Poker.
After he wanders off, you'll get a tutorial on how to play Poker. For the Gold Medal, you need to win at least two hands. You'll automatically win the first one as part of the tutorial, so just focus on winning one more. My advice? Don't bet too high. This gives you more chances to play if you happen to lose a hand, and you'll eventually snag that second win.
Once the Poker game wraps up, head outside to find the Reverend. He's gotten himself into a bit of a situation down the hill, tangling with his creditor. You'll need to step in and defend him. Go on the offensive and knock the guy down. This is your first real introduction to Red Dead Redemption 2's wanted system. Someone's going to see you do this.
Warning: If a witness spots you committing a crime, they'll run off to alert the law. But here's the trick: if you're quick enough, you can catch up to them. You can then either threaten them or even beat them into keeping quiet. Chase after the creditor's witness and threaten him to prevent the crime from being reported.
Unfortunately, the Reverend's gotten himself into trouble again and wandered onto the nearby railway tracks. Head over there and quickly help him off. Just follow the on-screen prompts to get him to safety.
The final part of this mission is escorting the Reverend home. You'll need to sling him onto your horse and gallop back to Horseshoe Overlook. You have a strict time limit of 2 minutes and 5 seconds to get him from the tracks, hitch the horse, and drop him into his bed. It sounds tight, but if you gallop the whole way, you'll have more than enough time since the camp is so close.
100% Human-Written. AI Fact-Checked. Community Verified. Learn how AntMag verifies content