Skip to content
[District] (112)
The Sinking City 2

[District] (112)

Walkthrough for the Agatha Pierce encounter in The Sinking City 2, including finding poisoned Chianti and unlocking the Crime, No Punishment trophy.

By ···10 min read·Multi-source verified
1 reading this guide  

Walkthrough for the Agatha Pierce encounter in The Sinking City 2, including finding poisoned Chianti and unlocking the Crime, No Punishment trophy.

Walkthrough
  1. 1
    Speak with Agatha Pierce. Choose "Okay, I'll do it." to progress.
  2. 2
    After the conversation, you will receive "Looking for Chianti" and "A rusty key" in your CASEBOOK under Self-Defense.
  3. 3
    Enter the basement. This will remove the "A rusty key" entry from your CASEBOOK.
  4. 4
    Proceed to the subbasement, defeating any wylebeasts (hostile creatures) you encounter.
  5. 5
    Locate the single upright bottle on crates opposite the stairs in the subbasement. Examine its label and cork.
  6. 6
    This action will remove the "Bottle of strychnine" CASEBOOK entry and grant you "Bottle of poisoned Chianti" (Key Evidence 3/4) under Self-Defense.
  7. 7
    Return upstairs to Agatha Pierce.
  8. 8
    Interact with her again. Choose "I have the bottle." then "I want to say a toast." followed by "To your good health."
  9. 9
    After this conversation, the "Bottle of poisoned Chianti" CASEBOOK entry will be removed. You will receive a new Mind Palace Clue "I killed the lady" and "I killed Agatha Pierce" (Key Evidence 4/4) under Self-Defense.
Tips
  • Interacting with Agatha Pierce and completing her objectives is crucial for the "Crime, No Punishment" (missable) achievement/trophy.
  • Make sure to examine both the label and cork of the poisoned Chianti bottle.
  • The "A rusty key" is only relevant until you enter the basement.

100% Human-Written. AI Fact-Checked. Community Verified. Learn how AntMag verifies content